Judge allows Trump's $15bn New York Times lawsuit to proceed
JournalismPakistan.com | Published: 20 November 2026 | JP Global Monitoring
Join our WhatsApp channel
A federal judge allowed parts of Donald Trump's $15bn defamation suit against The New York Times and Penguin Random House to proceed, dismissing two claims and narrowing dozens of allegations to seven specific statements; the surviving claims allege tax fraud, evasion and money laundering.Summary
TAMPA, Florida — A US federal judge has allowed part of President Donald Trump's $15 billion defamation lawsuit against The New York Times and book publisher Penguin Random House to proceed, rejecting their attempt to have the entire case dismissed.
The November 19 ruling by US District Judge Steven Merryday represents a partial legal victory for Trump, although the court substantially narrowed the lawsuit. Two claims were dismissed entirely, while four others were restricted to specific statements concerning alleged financial wrongdoing.
Court narrows disputed claims
The ruling reduced the number of potentially actionable statements from 34 to seven. Six surviving statements appeared in the 2024 book Lucky Loser: How Donald Trump Squandered His Father's Fortune and Created the Illusion of Success, written by New York Times journalists Susanne Craig and Russ Buettner. The seventh appeared in an article by Times journalist Peter Baker.
The remaining allegations concern statements suggesting Trump engaged in tax fraud, tax evasion, money laundering or related financial crimes. Merryday found that Trump's complaint sufficiently alleged that the journalists had made serious accusations without obtaining the expert assessment necessary to support them.
What the ruling means
The decision does not establish that the disputed statements were false or that the journalists acted unlawfully. It means only that Trump's allegations concerning the seven surviving statements are sufficient for the litigation to continue.
At the centre of the case is the American legal standard known as "actual malice", which requires public officials and public figures pursuing defamation claims to establish that a statement was published with knowledge of its falsity or reckless disregard for whether it was true. The standard, established in the landmark 1964 Supreme Court decision New York Times Co. v. Sullivan, provides significant protection for reporting on public figures.
Merryday concluded that Trump had adequately alleged actual malice at this preliminary stage in relation to the surviving statements. The court considered whether the journalists had sufficient grounds for allegations involving complex financial crimes and whether their reporting demonstrated a disregard for information necessary to establish the accuracy of those allegations.
Whether Trump can ultimately prove the required elements of defamation remains unresolved. The defendants will have further opportunities to contest the claims as the proceedings continue.
Newspaper and publisher reject allegations
The New York Times has maintained that the lawsuit lacks merit. Its spokesperson, Charlie Stadtlander, said the ruling eliminated almost all the claims directed against the newspaper and that it would continue defending its journalism and the rights of the independent press.
Penguin Random House also rejected Trump's allegations, reaffirming its support for the book and its authors and expressing confidence that the remaining case would eventually be dismissed.
Trump's legal team welcomed the decision, portraying it as an important victory in the president's challenge to reporting he considers defamatory.
The dispute originated in September 2025, when Trump sued over coverage examining his business history, inherited wealth and public image. The original complaint was rejected by the court for failing to present its allegations concisely, prompting subsequent revisions.
The lawsuit seeks at least $15 billion in damages. That figure represents Trump's demand, not an amount awarded or endorsed by the court.
Wider implications for press freedom
The litigation forms part of Trump's broader legal campaign against established news organizations over coverage he argues has damaged his reputation.
In another recent case, a federal judge allowed Trump's defamation lawsuit against the BBC to continue over an edited video clip. The broadcaster has denied liability. Other legal actions involving American media organizations have encountered different outcomes, demonstrating that the cases must be assessed individually.
For news organizations, the latest ruling highlights the potentially substantial legal consequences of investigative reporting about powerful public figures, particularly when published material contains allegations of criminal conduct.
It also reinforces the distinction between allowing a defamation complaint to proceed and determining that a publication committed defamation. The American courts must balance protection of reputation against constitutional safeguards for independent journalism.
The surviving New York Times claims could eventually require closer examination of the reporting and editorial decisions behind the disputed statements. For the newspaper and publisher, the immediate challenge is defending a narrower case that remains financially significant.
The outcome will be closely watched by media organizations beyond the United States because of its implications for investigative journalism, the legal risks of reporting on political leaders and the continuing interpretation of press protections under American law.
For now, neither side has secured a final victory. Trump has kept part of his case alive, while The New York Times and Penguin Random House have succeeded in eliminating most of the disputed statements from the lawsuit.
The central question of whether the remaining reporting constituted actionable defamation has yet to be decided.
ATTRIBUTION: Based on Reuters reporting published November 19, 2026, and Bloomberg reporting published November 20, 2026, including details of the federal court's ruling and statements from the parties.
PHOTO: Sergeitokmakov from Pixabay
Key Points
- Judge Steven Merryday allowed parts of the $15bn suit to proceed while dismissing two claims.
- The court narrowed potentially actionable statements from 34 to seven.
- Six of the surviving statements are from the 2024 book Lucky Loser; one is from a Times article.
- Surviving allegations concern tax fraud, tax evasion, money laundering or related financial wrongdoing.
- The ruling permits litigation to continue but does not determine truth or unlawful conduct.
Key Questions & Answers
What did the judge decide?
The judge allowed parts of the lawsuit to proceed, dismissed two claims, and narrowed the disputed statements to seven specific passages.
Which statements survived?
Six statements from the book Lucky Loser and one from a New York Times article survived the dismissal and remain in the case.
Do the surviving claims mean the statements were false?
No. The ruling only means the allegations are sufficient to continue in court; it does not establish falsity or unlawful conduct.
What are the surviving allegations about?
The remaining claims allege tax fraud, tax evasion, money laundering or related financial wrongdoing tied to Trump.
Ask AI: Understand this story your way
AI EnabledDig deeper, ask anything — get instant context, background, and clarity.
Disclaimer: This feature is powered by AI and is intended to help readers explore and understand news stories more easily. While we strive for accuracy, AI-generated responses may occasionally be incomplete or reflect limitations in the underlying model. This feature does not represent the editorial views of JournalismPakistan. For our full, verified reporting, please refer to the original article.













