JournalismPakistan.com | Published April 06, 2020
Join our WhatsApp channel
ISLAMABAD—Mainstream print and electronic news media in Pakistan seldom give comprehensive coverage to the matters vital to the people's lives, such as health, education, climate change, and gender unless there is a crisis or a controversy, according to a research study.
The study by Society for Alternative Media and Research (SAMAR) was conducted over ten months from February to November 2019. A total of 25 issues were selected for monitoring of the front, back, and the editorial pages of the mainstream Urdu, English and vernacular Pushto and Sindhi newspapers, and one main bulletin and one talk show on selected mainstream and regional TV channels.
The issues selected for monitoring were classified into two categories—people-focused and media-focused. The ten people-focused issues were water, climate change, food security, gender, education/students, labor and peasants, art, culture and literature, science and discovery, and agriculture.
To gauge which issues the print and electronic media were focusing on, a total of 15 issues were selected: Politics/Political parties/Statements, Government, Economy, Foreign Affairs/International, Parliament, Judiciary/Court Cases, Terrorism, Crime, Military, Entertainment, Sports, Advertisement, Energy, Weather, and Other (Specify).
A total of three English, three Urdu, and two regional newspapers, along with the main bulletins and talk shows of 15 TV channels were monitored.
According to the study, there is little space for people-focused issues on the front and back pages of the Urdu, English, Sindhi, and Pushto newspapers. Similarly, these issues also get short air time on TV channels.
Overall in the three English newspapers—Dawn, The News, and The Express Tribune—out of the 12423 news items on the front back and editorials, articles, and the letters to the editor on the opinion pages, only 1757 or 14.1% were regarding the people's issues. Less than 6% of news items on the front-back pages in the mainstream English newspapers were on the people's issues. The people-focused issues only make it to the front-back pages when there is a crisis such as the resurgence of polio cases, dengue, locust attack, or the current COVID-19 pandemic.
Though the front-back pages of the mainstream Urdu newspapers carry a large number of news items, focus on people's issues is scant. Overall out of the 32,129 news items, editorials, articles, and the letters to the editor on the front-back and the editorial pages of Dunya, Nawa-e-Waqt, and Express, only 1960 or 6% were regarding the people's issues. Only 2.81% of the news items on the front pages were on the people's issues. However, on the back page, there was more coverage—out of the total 17554 news items, 1549 or 8.8% were regarding the people's issues.
Similarly, on the front pages of the regional newspapers, only 4.8% or 470 of the total 9306 news items focused on the issues of health, education, gender, art, culture, climate change, water, farming, etc. There was little more space on the back page as 8.27% or 850 news items out of the total 10274 were about the ten issues.
However, focus on the people's issues slightly increases on the editorial pages. During the ten months' monitoring, 10% or 278 out of the total 2753 editorials in the three English dailies were on the people's issues. Similarly, almost one-fifth of the articles (19.6%) discussed the ten issues.
The three Urdu dailies discussed the people's issues in 278 (10%) editorials out of the total 2753 during the ten months. Similarly 12% or 476 articles out of the total 3958 took up issues regarding health, education, gender, food security, culture, language, art, agriculture, etc.
Surprisingly, there was high number of editorials on the people's issues in the Pushto and Sindhi newspapers. Editorials (43.2%) were on the people's issues. However, it seems that the regional dailies, especially those in Pushto, were struggling for generating fresh content. A number of editorials were found to be repeated.
Newspapers' readers want to see their issues discussed in the print. The people-focused issues were most discussed in the letters to the editor in the Urdu, English, and Sindhi newspapers. This section was missing in the monitored Pushto newspapers.
Out of the total 2950 letters to the editors in the three English dailies, 749 (25.3%) were regarding the issues of health, education, gender, food security, agriculture, culture, language, and science and discovery, etc. Out of the total 987 letters to the editor in the Urdu newspapers, 187 or 18.9% were regarding the ten selected issues. The letters to the editor section was missing in the Pushto newspapers while it was irregular in the Sindhi newspapers.
In the main bulletins and the talk shows of the mainstream TV channels, there seems to be little airtime for the issues critical for the people.
In the mainstream TV channels, out of the total 22115 news items included in the main bulletins, only 1570 or 7.09% were regarding the people's issues. In minutes this translates into only 6.91% of the airtime of the news bulletin and the talk shows on the people's issues.
Similarly, on the Sindhi and Pushto TV channels, out of the 18931 news items, only 1500 or 7.91% were about the people's issues. However, the situation is slightly better in terms of airtime allocation with 11.74% of airtime during the bulletins and talk shows given to the people's issues.
The study added the focus of the print and electronic media remains on foreign affairs, international news, politics, statements, political developments, court cases, economy, and the government. The people-focused issues only get space on the front-back pages or a mention in the main bulletin/talk shows when there is a crisis, a scandal, or a clash that leads to the loss of life or property. Talk shows are not inclined to put in extra effort to probe issues related to health, education, climate change, art, literature, food security, etc.
Newspapers do give space to the people-focused issues but on the city and national pages. However, here again most of the stories on the people-focused issues are in the form of reporting of events. These may be seminars, workshops, or launches of reports by NGOs or donor-funded projects.
January 13, 2025: An analysis of Absar Alam's controversial criticism of successful Pakistani YouTubers in exile, examining the intersection of journalism, digital media success, and political persecution, while questioning the credibility of criticism from a former PEMRA chief whose own appointment was declared illegal.
January 13, 2025: Prominent journalist Asma Shirazi faces relentless online harassment in a coordinated campaign involving gendered disinformation. Press freedom groups demand immediate action to protect female journalists in Pakistan.
January 10, 2025: The FIA Cyber Wing is investigating a social media campaign involving AI-manipulated images of Maryam Nawaz and UAE President Mohammed bin Zayed. Teams are working to trace the content's origins and identify those involved.
January 05, 2025: JournalismPakistan.com welcomes renowned cricket historian and broadcaster Dr. Nauman Niaz as sports editor, bringing his extensive experience in cricket journalism, broadcasting, and scholarly work to strengthen the platform's sports coverage.
January 01, 2025: Trump envoy Richard Grenell's sudden week-long silence on Pakistan and Imran Khan raises questions after fierce Twitter battles with journalists and politicians. From explosive exchanges to mysterious quiet - what's behind the digital retreat?
December 31, 2024: Year-end report by Pakistan Press Foundation reveals severe challenges to press freedom in Pakistan, highlighting violence against journalists, internet shutdowns, and restrictive policies in 2024.
December 30, 2024: Remembering Arshad A. Zuberi, the deputy chief executive of Business Recorder Group, who passed away on Sunday after a protracted illness, leaving behind a remarkable legacy in journalism.
December 29, 2024: Veteran journalist Nusrat Javeed has accused PTI of operating a bot in Richard Grenell’s name, fueling a Twitter controversy amid the Trump aide’s vocal support for Imran Khan.
January 12, 2025 Explore an in-depth analysis of Pakistan cricket's decline in Test matches, examining systemic failures, cultural challenges, and the urgent need for modernization. From mismanagement of talents like Babar Azam and Shaheen Afridi to resistance against technological advancement, this comprehensive piece investigates how a cricket powerhouse finds itself at a critical crossroads between tradition and progress.
January 09, 2025 Shan Masood's magnificent 145 and a record-breaking opening stand with Babar Azam highlighted Pakistan's valiant fight against South Africa in Cape Town. Despite their resilience, Pakistan fell short, reflecting on deeper cricketing issues.
January 05, 2025 An in-depth analysis of Virat Kohli's recent struggles in Test cricket, examining his technical changes, statistical decline since 2021, and the broader implications for his legacy as one of cricket's greatest batsmen. The article explores whether this is a temporary setback or signals the twilight of an extraordinary career.
January 05, 2025 Pulitzer Prize-winning Washington Post cartoonist Ann Telnaes resigns after her cartoon depicting media moguls, including Post owner Jeff Bezos, kneeling before Donald Trump was rejected, sparking debate about editorial independence and press freedom.
January 03, 2025 Explore the poignant narrative of cricket's fallen captains, focusing on Rohit Sharma's Test career crisis and its parallels with legendary leaders Kim Hughes, Ian Botham, and Steve Waugh. A deep dive into cricket's most tragic leadership endings.