Defense Ministry complaint presses for cancellation of Geo TV license

JournalismPakistan.com | Published: 23 April 2014

The Ministry of Defense has lodged a complaint against Geo TV, alleging that the network has breached its license terms. This includes accusations of spreading false and scandalous information about state institutions, notably the ISI.
Summary

ISLAMABAD: The Ministry of Defense in its complaint to PEMRA says the Independent Media Corporation (Geo) has violated the terms and conditions of license issued to them which therefore makes them liable for measures including cancellation of license by the regulatory authority.

The text of the complaint: Subject: Complaint against Independent Media Corporation (Pvt) Ltd (Geo) for taking action under the PEMRA ordinance and the rules for false and scandalous campaign undermining the integrity and tarnishing the image of state institution (ISI) and its officers

On 19th April, 2014, an incident of firing apparently an assassination attempt was made by some unknown assailants at around 1730 hours at Karachi on Mr Hamid Mir, an anchor person associated with Geo News, a venture held and operated by M/S Independent Media Corporation (Pvt) Limited, Karachi.

Immediately, thereafter, a vicious campaign, libelous and scandalous in nature was started, initially on Geo News channel wherein false accusations were made against a state institution tasked to work for defense, sovereignty and integrity of Pakistan i.e Inter Services Intelligence (ISI) and its DG, Lt. Gen Muhammad Zahir ul Islam.

The telecast in question/campaign was aimed at undermining the integrity and tarnishing the image of state institution and its officers and falsely linking it with the terrorist outfit/activities. The attempt was detrimental to the interest of the institution and the country.

Said footage was picked up by foreign media, particularly Indian channels who instead of objectively reporting the incident overplayed it repeatedly. Geo Network made extensive reporting on the incident primarily aimed at targeting a state institution and its DG. The entire electronic media covered the said incident as 'Breaking News' as well as in 'News Bulletins' and the tickers. Details are provided in the CDs along with script as Annexure A & B. The said reporting has violated the specific terms and conditions of its license.

The reporting made and the programs aired cannot be viewed as a single event. Geo Network has a history of acting illegally in furtherance of anti-Pakistan agenda. If required, material can be provided to the regulator. The inability of the editorial team and management or monitoring staff at Geo failed to either control the content and deliberately allowed scandalous views to go on air. This constitutes breach of terms of its license and violating code of conduct. Moreover, the above instance establishes that the editorial team and management of Geo has clearly violated the following provisions of PEMRA rules/code of conduct, making Geo liable for cancellation of its license:

a. Rule 15 of PEMRA rules

b. Para (c) (g) (i) of standing code of conduct

c. Section 20(a) of PEMRA Ordinance

d. Section 27(a) of PEMRA Ordinance

The above be read with all enabling provisions of the PEMRA Ordinance and the Rules as amended from time to time.

The print media, particularly the newspapers published by Jang and The News also published defamatory, libelous and scandalous material as has been done by their sister concerns in electronic media. The management thereof followed suit and joined hands for doing the above illegal acts. This makes the said publications and the persons responsible for actions under i) section 3, 4, 9 of the Defamation Ordinance 2002, ii) Section 19 and 27 of the Press, Newspaper, News Agencies and Book Registration Ordinance 2002 and the Rules framed there-under and also the terms and conditions of the licenses/declarations granted or operated there-under and iii) the measures and mechanism under the Press Council of Pakistan Ordinance 2002.

The said false, malicious and irresponsible reporting is a continuation of policy of Geo Network for maligning the state institutions as it has done earlier in the case of Daniel Pearl, Wali Khan Babar, the killing of Mr Hamaad (an officer of Supreme Court of Pakistan) and also the killing of parents of an honorable judge of the Supreme Court at Lahore. The malicious reporting later proved false.

The violations of terms of conditions of license issued by PEMRA to Independent Media Corporation (Pvt) Limited make the network liable for measures including the cancellation of license by PEMRA.

KEY POINTS: