Journalism Pakistan
Pakistan: Asma Shirazi hits back, calling Moeed Pirzada's criticism 'political hypocrisy'Pakistan: Journalists face new restrictions on recording in National AssemblyPakistan: Journalist Moeed Pirzada criticizes Asma Shirazi's comments on UK deportationsPakistan: Geo News faces 'technical glitch' on Trump-Imran Khan mentionOpportunities: James B. Steele Fellowship offers full support for aspiring business journalistsPakistan: Dare to investigate? Asad Ali Toor confronts investigative journalists on Panjutha's abductionPakistan: The Nation scrubs controversial article on US lawmakers after editor denies rolePakistan: Dawn calls for action to end impunity against journalistsWorld: Mexican journalist Paty Bunbury shot deadOpportunities: Tarbell grants boost AI journalism with awards up to $15,000World: Financial laws misused to intimidate journalists globally, UNESCO study revealsPakistan: Journalist urges New York Times to reevaluate partnership with The Nation

Pakistan's journalists complain of increasing censorship

 JournalismPakistan.com |  Published December 26, 2018 |  By Kathy Gannon (The Associated Press)

Join our WhatsApp channel

 Pakistan's journalists complain of increasing censorship

ISLAMABAD - Pakistani journalists, who have taken on military dictators and been beaten and jailed in the pursuit of a free press, say they now face a form of censorship that is more subtle but no less chilling, one spearheaded by the security services.

Journalists and press freedom advocates say the military and the powerful Inter-Services Intelligence agency, or ISI, are pressuring media outlets to quash critical coverage. The newly-elected government is meanwhile slashing its advertising budget, squeezing a key source of revenue for private newspapers and TV stations.

Qazi Salauddin, a veteran Pakistani journalist who has witnessed successive periods of direct military rule, said today's censorship is the worst it's ever been.

"Today we don't know what will annoy them," he said of the military. "Today we have to do self-censorship, and that is the worst kind of censorship because it is done out of fear."

Websites have been shut down, including the Urdu website of the U.S. government-funded Voice of America, after it reported on a tribal movement critical of military operations in regions bordering Afghanistan. Mashaal Radio, affiliated with Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, has also been shut down.

Journalist Cyril Almeida was charged with treason after he published an interview with Nawaz Sharif in which the former prime minister accused the Pakistani military of aiding the militants who carried out the 2008 Mumbai attacks.

Authorities are also targeting social media, asking Twitter to suspend accounts and submitting thousands of requests to Facebook to take down pages for a variety of reasons, ranging from criticism of the military to propagating hate and insulting Islam.

Taha Siddiqui, a blogger, and journalist who is critical of the security services, lives in self-imposed exile in France after an attempt on his life earlier this year, which he blamed on the ISI. He said Twitter suspended his account twice in 72 hours, telling him it was because of "objectionable content that was in violation of Pakistani law," without elaborating.

Journalist Matiullah Jan, labeled "anti-state" by the military for his criticism of the judiciary and army, called the crackdown "a systematic attempt by the military and its intelligence agency to assert control with a facade of a democratically elected government."

New legislation regulating print and online media has also alarmed press freedom advocates, who fear it will grant authorities even more censorship tools.

Information Minister Fawad Chaudhry denies the government is cracking down on press freedoms, saying it only acts to prevent incitement to violence. Pakistan has banned coverage of the hard-line Tehreek-e-Labbaik movement after it held violent protests and threatened to kill a Christian woman who was acquitted of blasphemy charges after years spent on death row.

"Pakistan has the freest media possible, and powerful media criticize the government and even agencies and (the) army establishment at their will," Chaudhry told The Associated Press. "Incitement of hatred is the only area that we interfere."

But journalists say the interference goes much further and has worsened since July's national elections. They say intelligence agents have called reporters to demand that opinion pieces be withdrawn and to quash investigative reports on allegations that the military intervened in the vote to help elect Prime Minister Imran Khan.

The security establishment is especially sensitive about coverage of the Pashtun Tahafaz (Protection) Movement, or PTM, which has criticized the military's actions in the tribal regions. Pakistan has long been accused of covertly supporting the Afghan Taliban while waging a scorched-earth campaign against homegrown extremists who threaten the state, allegations denied by the government.

"We have been facing a media blackout since the very first day," said Mohsin Dawar, a parliamentarian and founding member of the PTM. "The military now is enjoying unquestioned power in the country, and the PTM questioned their power."

Dawar said newspapers have refused to carry their statements or cover their press conferences.

Chaudhry said coverage of PTM is restricted because "we have fought a war in that area."

"The population is in process of settling down, (and a) narrative that creates hatred cannot be allowed," he said.

Steven Butler, Asia program coordinator for the Committee to Protect Journalists, said Pakistan had waged an "aggressive crackdown" on the media.

"The crackdown comes behind the scenes and is increasingly exerted through the owners of media properties," he said.

There are currently 89 private television channels licensed by the government. Most of the privately-owned channels emerged in just the last 15 years and are owned by big businesses, said Mohammad Ziauddin of the Pakistan Press Foundation, a free press advocacy group.

"The new entrants in the media are business people. They got into the media industry not to make money, not to serve the public, but to have clout," he said, making them vulnerable to intimidation and financial coercion.

In the last two months, hundreds of journalists have been laid off as government advertising — a key source of revenue — has been drastically reduced. A rate schedule seen by the AP shows the government was until recently paying upward of $2,500 for a 60-second spot, which has now been reduced to $400 to $500.

"While reliance on government revenues is not a healthy model for press freedom, the sudden cutbacks have imposed extreme hardship on the media, which has had basically no time to adjust business models," Butler said.

Chaudhry defends the new rate schedule, saying previous governments paid well above the market rate in return for positive coverage.

"The last government used television advertising as tool to bribe media," he said. - AP/Photo: B.K.Bangash

Asma Shirazi hits back, calling Moeed Pirzada's criticism 'political hypocrisy'

Asma Shirazi hits back, calling Moeed Pirzada's criticism 'political hypocrisy'

 November 09, 2024:  In a sharp rebuttal, anchor Asma Shirazi responded to Moeed Pirzada's allegations, calling him a one-time puppet of the establishment and questioning his commitment to democratic values and human rights.

Journalists face new restrictions on recording in National Assembly

Journalists face new restrictions on recording in National Assembly

 November 08, 2024:  The National Assembly of Pakistan has banned all video recording within Parliament House, citing privacy concerns raised by lawmakers over journalists’ interviews being posted on social media without consent. Violators may face confiscation of devices and restricted access.

Journalist Moeed Pirzada criticizes Asma Shirazi's comments on UK deportations

Journalist Moeed Pirzada criticizes Asma Shirazi's comments on UK deportations

 November 08, 2024:  Pakistani journalist Moeed Pirzada, living in exile, criticizes TV anchor Asma Shirazi for enthusiastically supporting the deportation of Pakistanis in the UK who protested against former Chief Justice Qazi Faiz Esa, accusing her of disregarding democracy and free speech.

Geo News faces 'technical glitch' on Trump-Imran Khan mention

Geo News faces 'technical glitch' on Trump-Imran Khan mention

 November 06, 2024:  Geo News' coverage of the US elections took an unusual turn when the mention of Imran Khan was silenced on air. A "technical fault" muted Donald Trump’s remarks as he reportedly discussed the former Pakistani PM.

Dare to investigate? Asad Ali Toor confronts investigative journalists on Panjutha's abduction

Dare to investigate? Asad Ali Toor confronts investigative journalists on Panjutha's abduction

 November 04, 2024:  Journalist Asad Ali Toor has challenged Pakistan's investigative journalists, calling them "touts of the establishment," to cover the recent kidnapping of Imran Khan's lawyer, Intizar Hussain Panjutha, who was found beaten and tortured. In a widely circulated video, Toor questioned their integrity and called for unbiased investigation into the case.

The Nation scrubs controversial article on US lawmakers after editor denies role

The Nation scrubs controversial article on US lawmakers after editor denies role

 November 04, 2024:  The Nation has removed a story on US Congress members supporting Imran Khan's release after editor Salman Masood denied involvement. The story sparked a debate over editorial oversight and accusations of conspiratorial narratives.

Dawn calls for action to end impunity against journalists

Dawn calls for action to end impunity against journalists

 November 02, 2024:  On the International Day to End Impunity for Crimes Against Journalists, Pakistan’s Daily Dawn urges the state to take decisive action to protect journalists and ensure accountability, citing threats in Gaza, Pakistan, and beyond where media professionals face unprecedented risks.

Journalist urges New York Times to reevaluate partnership with The Nation

Journalist urges New York Times to reevaluate partnership with The Nation

 October 28, 2024:  A former reporter of The Nation appeals to New York Times Chairman A.G. Sulzberger, urging reconsideration of their publishing partnership over alleged unpaid salaries at the Pakistani newspaper.

Newsroom
James B. Steele Fellowship offers full support for aspiring business journalists

James B. Steele Fellowship offers full support for aspiring business journalists

 November 04, 2024 The James B. Steele Fellowship in Investigative Business Journalism offers aspiring journalists comprehensive training and a master's degree from the Cronkite School to develop skills in holding corporations accountable and delivering essential news to the public.

Vietnamese blogger handed 12-year prison sentence for anti-state propaganda

Vietnamese blogger handed 12-year prison sentence for anti-state propaganda

 November 01, 2024 Duong Van Thai, an independent Vietnamese blogger who went missing in Thailand, was sentenced to 12 years in prison on anti-state charges. CPJ condemns the harsh sentence, urging his immediate release and the Vietnamese state to end its crackdown on press freedom.

Mexican journalist Paty Bunbury shot dead

Mexican journalist Paty Bunbury shot dead

 November 01, 2024 The tragic killing of journalist Patricia Ramírez Gonzalez marks the second journalist murdered within 24 hours in Colima, Mexico, spotlighting urgent concerns over press safety in President Claudia Sheinbaum’s administration.

Tarbell grants boost AI journalism with awards up to $15,000

Tarbell grants boost AI journalism with awards up to $15,000

 October 31, 2024 Tarbell Grants offer awards of $1,000 to $15,000 for journalists covering artificial intelligence. These grants support investigative and explanatory stories on AI’s impacts, company practices, and policy lobbying efforts. Apply now to make a difference in AI accountability.

Financial laws misused to intimidate journalists globally, UNESCO study reveals

Financial laws misused to intimidate journalists globally, UNESCO study reveals

 October 28, 2024 UNESCO's latest report highlights the misuse of financial laws to silence journalists, with findings showing a sharp rise in financial crime allegations against journalists globally. This growing trend poses serious threats to press freedom and media independence.