Dawn sticks to its stand on October 6 story, says ECL was a 'misstep'

 JournalismPakistan.com |  Published 9 years ago

ISLAMABAD – Dawn reiterated Sunday it continues to stand by its October 6 story that rocked the government and the military.

In an editorial headlined ‘ECL misstep’ the paper said: “This newspaper continues to stand by the news item in question and robustly defend its right to report independently, without fear or favour.”

The paper said: “The government can, of course, continue with an investigation into where the leaks came from if it so deems fit; Dawn is willing to cooperate in such an inquiry, but reserves its right to protect its sources.”

The author of the story Act against militants or face international isolation, civilians tell military was senior journalist Cyril Almeida. He was put on Exit Control List by the government on October 10 for this story on a high-level national security meeting highlighting civil-military tensions.

His name was however, struck off the list five days later, following pressure from media practitioners, international press freedom watchdogs and others.

“With the removal from the Exit Control List of senior Dawn journalist Cyril Almeida’s name, better sense seems to have prevailed,” the paper commented.

“In resorting to the extraordinary measure of placing his name on the ECL, the government had set itself on an ill-judged course that would have had a highly adverse impact on this country’s hard-won press freedoms, the independence of the media, and the public’s right to stay informed.”

Dawn said that given “the current government’s oft-repeated respect for media freedom, the placing of a journalist’s name on the ECL as reprisal for the publishing of a contentious report was as unexpected as it was erosive of ethical values. Such a misstep must not recur – it must be ensured that the ECL sticks to its original purpose.”

Dive Deeper

Dawn apologizes after AI editing prompt mistakenly published in business story

 November 12, 2025: Dawn apologizes after an AI editing prompt mistakenly appeared in a business story, prompting debate on newsroom AI use and media credibility in Pakistan.

JournalismPakistan launches ‘Once Upon a Newsroom’ to preserve the legacy of The Muslim newspaper

 November 11, 2025: JournalismPakistan announces 'Once Upon a Newsroom', a storytelling series celebrating Pakistan’s newsroom heritage, beginning with The Muslim, the now-defunct independent daily from Islamabad.

Pakistani media in turmoil as job cuts, censorship, and silence from unions deepen crisis

 November 09, 2025: Pakistan’s media reels under layoffs, censorship, and union silence as journalists face attacks, fake news, and closures, deepening a nationwide media crisis.

JournalismPakistan unveils new tagline marking global expansion

 November 08, 2025: JournalismPakistan.com launches its new tagline, Linking Journalism Worldwide, reflecting global expansion beyond Pakistan with Asia, World, and Middle East coverage.

Veteran journalist Javed Iqbal Jaidi bids farewell after long health battle

 November 08, 2025: Veteran journalist Javed Iqbal Jaidi passes away in Shorkot after a long illness. Friends remember his humor, humility, and lifelong dedication to journalism.

JournalismPakistan.com launches dedicated Middle East section to deepen regional media coverage

 November 07, 2025: JournalismPakistan.com launches a Middle East section to expand regional reporting. New coverage will follow JP’s editorial SOPs—verification, balanced sourcing, and two-stage review.

Russia slams Pakistan’s Frontier Post for ‘Western bias’; newspaper hits back

 November 07, 2025: Russia accuses Pakistan’s Frontier Post of anti-Russia bias; the paper defends press freedom and independence. A diplomatic clash over media narratives.

Javed Chaudhry signs off from Express News after 18 years on ‘Kal Tak’

 November 07, 2025: Veteran journalist Javed Chaudhry bids farewell to Express News after 18 years on Kal Tak, marking the end of an era in Pakistani television journalism.