Kyrgyzstan declares outlets Kloop and Temirov Live ‘extremist’ in unprecedented crackdown Babar Azam's form slump: Inside the psychological battle and classical crisis of Pakistan's cricket maestro New York Times opens 2025 fellowship for emerging journalists CPJ slams Turkey’s seizure of TELE1, calls for journalist’s release Alfred Friendly launches 2026 fellowship for exiled journalists in America Harvard invites applications for 2026 Nieman Journalism Fellowships IFJ, global unions urge ASEAN to reject Myanmar junta’s planned sham election Justice denied: Mother of slain journalist Arshad Sharif dies awaiting accountability CNN's Christiane Amanpour reveals recurrence of ovarian cancer PSL's decline: From cricket's bright promise to bureaucratic mediocrity and franchise crisis
Journalism Pakistan
Journalism Pakistan

Pakistan's independent online journalism group rejects new content rules as draconian

 JournalismPakistan.com |  Published 4 years ago

Join our WhatsApp channel

Pakistan's independent online journalism group rejects new content rules as draconian

LAHORE—The federal government’s newly notified regulations aiming to curb online content can only help diminish the fundamental rights of freedom of expression and access guaranteed in the Constitution of Pakistan and should be revoked immediately. 

The Association of Pakistan’s Independent Online Journalism Platforms that groups together professional online forums practicing public interest journalism said this in a joint statement on Friday.

“The recently notified ‘the Removal and Blocking of Unlawful Online Content (Procedure, Oversight and Safeguards) Rules 2020’ under the controversial ‘the Prevention of Electronic Crimes Act 2016’ are against the people’s rights to express themselves and seek and impart information of interest to them and should be immediately reversed,” the association said.

The joint statement said the rules, supposedly formed to operationalize the problematic and contentious Section 37 of the PECA law, have not only gone beyond the bounds of its parent law but also attempted to give new meanings to Article 19 of the Constitution, which is unacceptable.

“In principle, such rules can be made for the operation of the law and cannot amend the law or expand its scope or bring substantive changes in the law. However, these new rules attempt to give new definitions such as ‘community guidelines,’ ‘social media’ and ‘social media company’ which are not given in the PECA law,” the association said. 

The rules also define the terminology given in Article 19 of the Constitution such as ‘glory of Islam,’ ‘integrity, security and defense of Pakistan,’ ‘public order’ and ‘decency and morality,’ the statement said.

“It appears that by defining these terms, the rules have overstepped the exclusive jurisdiction of the constitutional courts to interpret and construe constitutional provisions.”

The rules give power to PTA (Pakistan Telecom Authority) to impose a penalty up to Rs500 million whereas, other than the offense of Cyber Terrorism under PECA, a maximum penalty of Rs10 million may be imposed on the repetition of an offense or violation of ‘directives’ of the government or PTA by an owner of an information system. “This is an obvious deviation of the rules from the parent law. It is beside the question of whether PTA is a court and can adjudicate an offense,” the statement said.

The association said it was disturbed that the rule gives the authority to PTA to direct a service provider, social media company, owner of the information system, owner of internet website or web server to remove or block access to any [allegedly] unlawful content, which it termed as sweeping powers that undermined fundamental constitutional guarantees.

“Adjudication of rights, including the right to freedom of expression is the domain of constitutional courts. By giving this authority to declare whether the content is lawful or unlawful an administrative body like PTA is against the vires of the constitution and principles determined by the superior judiciary for adjudication of constitutional rights,” the joint statement said.

The association said it supports the argument of the Asian Internet Coalition that “the draconian data localization requirements will damage the ability of people to access a free and open internet and shut Pakistan’s digital economy off from the rest of the world.”

The Association of Pakistan’s Independent Online Journalism Platforms currently groups together 13 current affairs independent online media groups from across Pakistan including Balochistan 24, Balochistan Voices, HumSub, IBC Pakistan, Journalism Pakistan, Native Media, Naya Daur, Sabaat, Sujag, Tajziat, TheReporters, Tribal News Network, and Voicepk.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Don't Miss These

Independent and unbroken: JournalismPakistan.com turns 16

Independent and unbroken: JournalismPakistan.com turns 16

 October 24, 2025: JournalismPakistan.com celebrates 16 years of independent reporting and media insight. Founded in 2009, the platform has weathered censorship, cyberattacks, and financial pressures to remain a trusted space for all who love and follow the media.

Newsroom
Kyrgyzstan declares outlets Kloop and Temirov Live ‘extremist’ in unprecedented crackdown

Kyrgyzstan declares outlets Kloop and Temirov Live ‘extremist’ in unprecedented crackdown

 October 29, 2025 In a historic first, a Bishkek court declares Kloop, Temirov Live, and their founders extremist, marking Kyrgyzstan’s sharpest assault on press freedom under President Japarov.


Babar Azam's form slump: Inside the psychological battle and classical crisis of Pakistan's cricket maestro

Babar Azam's form slump: Inside the psychological battle and classical crisis of Pakistan's cricket maestro

 October 29, 2025 Babar Azam's form slump reveals a psychological battle between classical artistry and modern cricket demands. Inside the mind of Pakistan's maestro, struggling to rediscover flow.


 New York Times opens 2025 fellowship for emerging journalists

New York Times opens 2025 fellowship for emerging journalists

 October 29, 2025 The New York Times is accepting applications for its 2025 fellowship, a one-year journalism training program for emerging reporters, editors, and visual journalists. Deadline: November 19, 2025.


CPJ slams Turkey’s seizure of TELE1, calls for journalist’s release

CPJ slams Turkey’s seizure of TELE1, calls for journalist’s release

 October 29, 2025 CPJ calls on Turkey to release journalist Merdan Yanardag and return control of TELE1, after his arrest on espionage charges and state media takeover.


Alfred Friendly launches 2026 fellowship for exiled journalists in America

Alfred Friendly launches 2026 fellowship for exiled journalists in America

 October 29, 2025 Alfred Friendly Press Partners invites exiled journalists in the US to apply for its 2026 four-week fellowship offering training, support, and a $2,000 stipend.