JournalismPakistan.com | Published last month | JP Special Report
Join our WhatsApp channel
ISLAMABAD — Veteran journalist and vlogger Rizwan Razi, popularly known as Razi Dada, has found himself at the center of a storm after his apology for controversial remarks about Sindhis was rejected, leading to calls for the Pakistan Telecommunication Authority (PTA) to block his YouTube channel. What began as a parliamentary rebuke has now evolved into a national debate on hate speech, accountability, and freedom of expression in Pakistan.
From Apology to Rejection
Razi came under fire for using derogatory language in a vlog, a move that angered Sindhi communities and drew strong condemnation in the Senate Standing Committee on Information. Although Razi quickly released a video apology admitting fault, his critics—including lawmakers—remained unconvinced. He was dismissed from his job, summoned before the Senate, and, according to his own words, “humiliated” during proceedings. Despite his contrition, the committee recommended a ban on his YouTube channel.
A Divided Media Community
The decision has sparked sharp divides in Pakistan’s media circles. Senior journalist Azaz Syed publicly defended Razi, stressing that the apology should have been accepted. “How much punishment are you going to give for one crime?” he asked on X, pointing out that no similar parliamentary scrutiny had been applied to powerful mafias or entrenched corruption. Others, however, argue that ethnic hate speech cannot be brushed aside with a mere apology and must carry consequences to protect national cohesion.
Social Media Solidarity
Supporters have mobilized online, launching hashtags such as #PunjabStandsWithRaziDada and #StayStrongRaziDada. His defenders frame the controversy as a case of selective justice, highlighting how ordinary journalists face disproportionate scrutiny compared to political and corporate elites. Images and banners circulating online portray Razi as a victim of state excess and a symbol of Punjab’s defiance.
A Troubled Past With Institutions
Razi is no stranger to friction with authorities. In 2019, he was briefly detained by the Federal Investigation Agency (FIA) over his social media posts critical of state policies. His recent tweet referenced past struggles: being “kicked off PTV,” threatened with bans, and subjected to character assassination. For his supporters, this latest episode is just another chapter in his long battle against censorship.
Beyond Razi: The Bigger Question
At its core, the controversy reflects Pakistan’s uneasy struggle to define the boundaries between free expression and hate speech. While critics view Razi’s remarks as harmful and divisive, supporters warn that punishing journalists even after apologies sets a dangerous precedent, discouraging debate and eroding press freedom.
For now, Razi Dada remains banned from PTV, under threat of losing his YouTube platform, and at the heart of one of Pakistan’s most heated debates about media ethics and accountability. What is clear is that his case has transcended one man’s words, becoming a symbol of Pakistan’s unresolved tensions between censorship, responsibility, and freedom.
November 06, 2025: Information Minister Attaullah Tarar’s job offer to Nukta staff draws criticism as hundreds of journalists across Pakistan face layoffs, salary delays, and job insecurity.
November 06, 2025: Information Minister Attaullah Tarar announces jobs for 37 laid-off Nukta employees, saying they will be placed at digital platforms within 48 hours amid growing media uncertainty.
November 05, 2025: PTI’s Faisal Chaudhry’s witty reply to Gharidah Farooqi on GTV’s “G for Gharidah” goes viral as a clip from their debate over the 27th Amendment sparks reactions online.
November 05, 2025: Digital platform Nukta lays off 37 employees in Pakistan, including journalists and producers, highlighting the financial struggles facing new media ventures in a shrinking job market.
November 04, 2025: Talat Hussain denies airing the viral clip showing Sher Afzal Marwat’s vulgar remark, saying it was not part of his Samaa TV show.
November 03, 2025: PFUJ recalls November 3, 2007, as Pakistan’s darkest day under Musharraf, urging protection for journalists and the abolition of laws threatening press freedom.
November 02, 2025: PFUJ urges Pakistan’s federal and provincial governments to end Impunity for Crimes Against Journalists and ensure their safety and press freedom.
November 02, 2025: Impunity for crimes against journalists deepens worldwide as Pakistan reports a 60 percent surge in attacks and weak enforcement of safety laws.
November 05, 2025 The Pulitzer Center is offering global reporting grants for journalists worldwide, funding high-impact projects on underreported issues with rolling applications in 2025.
November 04, 2025 Journalist Rana Ayyub receives death threats over calls demanding a column on the 1984 anti-Sikh riots as CPJ urges swift action to protect journalists in India.
November 04, 2025 TV8 journalist Mariana Rata in Moldova receives a death threat after interviewing politician Renato Usatii on-air, raising concerns about journalist safety.
November 03, 2025 Global journalist unions condemn the Indonesian agriculture minister’s lawsuit against Tempo, calling it a threat to press freedom and demanding that the case be withdrawn.
November 02, 2025 Independent outlet All About Macau to halt print and online operations amid rising pressure, financial strain, and legal threats, sparking press freedom concerns in the city.