US documentary filmmakers face prison for filming protest

 JournalismPakistan.com |  Published October 21, 2016

NEW YORK -  Prosecutors in the US states of North Dakota and Washington should drop all charges against three independent documentary filmmakers arrested while filming environmental activists interfering with oil pipelines, the Committee to Protect Journalists said Thursday.

Filmmakers Deia Schlosberg and Lindsey Goodwin-Grayzel, as well as Goodwin-Grayzel's cameraman, Carl Davis, were arrested with activists from the group Climate Direct Action on October 11, and subsequently charged with a range of felonies, including conspiracy and burglary, as participants in the coordinated, multistate protest, according to press reports.

"Recording civil disobedience and arrests is news-gathering, not conspiracy," said Robert Mahoney, CPJ's deputy executive director. "Prosecuting filmmakers for covering protests sends a chilling message. We call on authorities in North Dakota and Washington to drop these troubling charges and to stop interfering with journalists doing their jobs."

Schlosberg, the founder of the Pale Blue Dot Media Company, told CPJ that she faces a maximum sentence of 25 years on conspiracy charges for filming activist Michael Foster as he broke into a facility of the TransCanada Keystone Pipeline in North Dakota and closed a pipeline valve. Schlosberg said that she was arrested along with Foster and his fellow activist Samuel Jessup on October 11 and jailed for 53 hours before being released on bail.

According to the criminal complaint, which CPJ has reviewed, prosecutors claim that Schlosberg conspired with Foster and Jessup to damage the pipeline. The complaint says that Schlosberg was recruited to film the action and that she traveled in the same vehicle as the activists. If convicted either of the charge "conspiracy to theft of property" or "conspiracy to theft of service" -- Schlosberg told CPJ that the court could convict her of one or the other felony, but not both - she could face 20 years in prison, in addition to a maximum sentence of five years in prison for "conspiracy to tampering with or damaging a public service."

Schlosberg, who recently produced the third film in an Emmy award-winning series about natural gas production in the United States, told CPJ that she was not involved in the protest but that she was recording it as part of her work as a documentary filmmaker who focuses on environmental issues. She said she traveled with the activists, filming interviews in the car. She told CPJ that she was on public property and that she identified herself as a journalist at the time of the arrest.

A spokesperson at the office of North Dakota Pembina County state's attorney, Ryan Bialas, told CPJ that the office had no comment on the case.

In Washington, filmmaker Lindsey Goodwin-Grayzel and her cameraman Carl Davis face felony charges for robbery and trespassing after filming activist Ken Ward as he broke into a Trans Mountain Pipeline facility in Skagit County and attempted to shut down a pipeline.

According to her website, Goodwin-Grayzel is working on a short documentary film following Ward. Her attorney, Neil Fox, told CPJ that she was filming in Skagit County as part of this project.

"She's doing a documentary. She's not an activist who is part of some concerted action or the film arm of Greenpeace. Her life's work is to make documentary films," Fox told CPJ in a telephone interview.

If convicted, Goodwin-Grayzel faces a maximum penalty of a total of 30 years in jail, fines of $46,000, or both, on charges of second-degree burglary, trespassing, criminal sabotage, and "assemblage of saboteurs," according to a statement the filmmaker emailed to CPJ.

The Skagit County Prosecuting Attorney's Office did not immediately respond to CPJ's request for comment.

Goodwin-Grayzel has previously worked on films about suicides, national parks, and electronic medical records, according to her website.

Cameraman Carl Davis's lawyer, Brit Mercer, told CPJ that her client faces the same charges as Goodwin-Grayzel. Davis has worked on documentaries for museums and aquariums, Mercer told CPJ. Davis had not coordinated or worked with the activists in any way, she said.

"This is a terrifying affront to the First Amendment. He was a journalist hired to do a job -- no more, no less," Mercer told CPJ.

Activists shut down pipeline facilities in the US states of Washington, Minnesota, Montana, and North Dakota on October 11 to protest global warming.

The arrest of the reporters filming the direct action comes shortly after broadcast journalist Amy Goodman was charged with trespassing for filming protests against a pipeline project in North Dakota. The charges were eventually dropped, and a court dismissed a second charge of rioting, Goodman reported on her show. - Committee to Protect Journalists/Image: Reuters
 

CPJ calls on Pakistani authorities to end harassment, deportation of Afghan journalists

 January 23, 2025:  CPJ exposes Pakistan's dangerous deportation of Afghan journalists fleeing Taliban persecution, highlighting critical human rights violations and press freedom challenges. #JournalistSafety

Cyber martial law: Authoritarian PECA legislation threatens digital expression in Pakistan

 January 23, 2025:  Pakistan's PECA Amendment exposes a dangerous assault on press freedom, creating a repressive social media regulatory framework that threatens digital expression and criminalizes journalism. #MediaFreedom #PakistanLaw #DigitalRights #Censorship #JournalismUnderThreat

When talk shows turn battlegrounds: The ugly face of Pakistani TV

 January 23, 2025:  An in-depth look at the recent scuffle on a Pakistani talk show, its implications for media ethics, and the urgent need for TV channels to uphold decorum during debates.

Over 300 PTV pensioners rally for dues, PFUJ slams management inaction

 January 22, 2025:  PFUJ condemns the neglect of PTV pensioners who protested in Islamabad for unpaid dues and benefits. Union urges authorities to resolve issues without delay.

PFUJ condemns PECA amendments as a betrayal by information minister

 January 22, 2025:  The PFUJ has condemned the new amendments to PECA 2016, describing them as unconstitutional and threatening press freedom. It warns of nationwide protests if the government doesn’t withdraw the bill.

Crackdown on AI-generated content: FIA targets 10 more suspects

 January 22, 2025:  The FIA has registered 18 cases, including against 10 more suspects, for sharing AI-generated images of Maryam Nawaz and the UAE President. The crackdown also targets those who liked or commented on the images.

Pakistan's digital hypocrisy: PM Shehbaz Sharif tweets Trump while citizens face X ban

 January 21, 2025:  Pakistan's PM Shehbaz Sharif congratulates Trump on X despite the year-long platform ban, sparking outrage over government double standards and digital censorship concerns.

Leaked justice: Journalists tweet Imran Khan's 14-year sentence before judge's verdict

 January 17, 2025:  In an unprecedented breach of judicial protocol, Pakistani journalists accurately revealed Imran Khan's 14-year sentence in the Al-Qadir case on social media 24 hours before the official verdict, raising serious questions about court independence