PFUJ calls for end to Impunity for Crimes Against Journalists
November 02, 2025: PFUJ urges Pakistan’s federal and provincial governments to end Impunity for Crimes Against Journalists and ensure their safety and press freedom.
JournalismPakistan.com | Published last month | JP Special Report
Join our WhatsApp channel
ISLAMABAD — The Senate’s Standing Committee on Rules of Procedure and Privileges has directed the Pakistan Telecommunication Authority (PTA) to block the YouTube channel of veteran journalist and vlogger Rizwan Razi—popularly known as Razi Dada—after he made derogatory remarks against the Sindhi community in a recent vlog.
The decision, made during a committee meeting chaired by Senator Syed Waqar Mehdi, has sparked a heated debate over the balance between curbing hate speech and protecting press freedom in Pakistan.
The Vlog That Sparked Controversy
Rizwan Razi, who runs the YouTube channel Razi Nama with over 289,000 subscribers, posted a vlog in which he used offensive language about Sindhis, calling them the “offspring of monkeys.” The remarks went viral on X (formerly Twitter), drawing sharp criticism from political circles, journalists, and civil society.
Lawmakers in the Senate meeting argued that Razi’s comments were not only derogatory but also harmful to federalism and inter-provincial harmony. The committee concluded that such content could inflame ethnic tensions and therefore recommended blocking his channel.
Termination by PTV and Apology
Before this latest Senate decision, Pakistan Television (PTV) had already terminated Razi’s services over the offensive vlog. Facing widespread backlash, Razi issued an apology acknowledging that his remarks were wrong. However, the committee decided that the apology was insufficient, citing the seriousness of the language used.
What the Ban Means for Press Freedom
The ban raises larger questions: Is blocking a journalist’s YouTube channel the right response—even after an apology? While few defend the offensive language, critics argue that banning platforms is a dangerous precedent in a country where press freedom has already been shrinking.
Pakistan has seen repeated crackdowns on television anchors, columnists, and reporters. With traditional media increasingly restricted, many journalists have shifted to YouTube and other digital platforms as their primary source of income and audience engagement.
By blocking Razi’s channel, authorities risk creating a chilling effect—not just on him but on countless other YouTubers who rely on digital platforms for survival. For many, YouTube is not only a space for expression but also their livelihood after being sidelined from print and broadcast media.
The Bigger Picture for Pakistani YouTubers
Pakistan’s digital media space has become a parallel press industry. Dozens of journalists forced out of mainstream television channels—often due to political pressure—have turned to YouTube to continue reporting and analysis. Channels like Razi’s, regardless of controversy, represent part of this new independent media ecosystem.
Blocking a channel for offensive remarks may address immediate outrage, but it also highlights the state’s growing role in policing digital spaces. Critics warn that such actions could escalate into broader censorship, where political criticism may also be curtailed under the guise of combating hate speech.
Where Does Pakistan Go from Here?
The Senate committee’s decision reflects a fundamental dilemma: how to draw the line between hate speech and free speech. On one hand, no society can allow derogatory, ethnic, or religious slurs to pass unchecked. On the other, blanket bans risk silencing dissenting voices and undermining democracy.
As Pakistan navigates this challenge, the case of Razi Dada serves as a test for the future of journalism and digital media. Will this be remembered as a justified clampdown on hate speech—or another blow to press freedom?
November 02, 2025: PFUJ urges Pakistan’s federal and provincial governments to end Impunity for Crimes Against Journalists and ensure their safety and press freedom.
November 02, 2025: Impunity for crimes against journalists deepens worldwide as Pakistan reports a 60 percent surge in attacks and weak enforcement of safety laws.
November 01, 2025: Pakistan Press Foundation reports 137 attacks on journalists in 2025, highlighting rising threats, legal harassment, and censorship on the International Day to End Impunity.
November 01, 2025: A viral Samaa TV clip featuring MNA Sher Afzal Marwat’s crude remarks and Talat Hussain’s laughter raises questions about the declining ethics of Pakistani television.
October 31, 2025: Police foiled a plot to kill DawnNewsTV journalist Tahir Naseer in Rawalpindi after arresting suspects hired for Rs200,000. Naseer says threats followed his reporting.
October 31, 2025: CPJ calls on Pakistan to bring Imtiaz Mir’s killers to justice after the journalist was allegedly murdered by a banned militant group in Karachi.
October 30, 2025: The PFUJ has condemned a fabricated drug case against journalist Matiullah Jan, calling it an attempt to silence him and urging authorities to quash the charges immediately.
October 30, 2025: NewsOne TV remains on air but faces mass layoffs and delayed salaries, exposing Pakistan’s worsening media crisis and financial instability.
November 02, 2025 Independent outlet All About Macau to halt print and online operations amid rising pressure, financial strain, and legal threats, sparking press freedom concerns in the city.
November 01, 2025 Belarus court jails journalist Siarhei Chabotska for extremism and defaming the president, highlighting Minsk’s ongoing crackdown on press freedom.
November 01, 2025 Mexican journalist Miguel Angel Beltran was found murdered in Durango. CPJ urges authorities to ensure justice amid rising violence against journalists in Mexico.
November 01, 2025 UNESCO survey finds one-third of media lawyers cannot effectively defend journalists due to threats, limited resources, and lack of specialization.
October 31, 2025 Radio Free Asia, a US government-funded broadcaster covering tightly controlled Asian media environments, has suspended all news operations after federal funding dried up.