JournalismPakistan.com | Published November 29, 2024 at 01:19 am
Join our WhatsApp channel
ISLAMABAD—The media coverage of the PTI's protest calling for the release of former Prime Minister Imran Khan mirrored the chaos of the demonstrations themselves. As the protest concluded following a police operation on Tuesday night, government circles celebrated while PTI members maintained a stance of defiance. Mainstream media coverage reflected this polarization, with stark differences in narratives.
A notable aspect of the protest was the uninterrupted accessibility of X (formerly Twitter) without a VPN, unlike previous instances of social media restrictions. Some analysts speculated that the platform was left open deliberately to counter PTI's online presence, while others attributed it to the influence of the protest.
Alternative media platforms played a prominent role in covering the events. YouTubers Matiullah Jan and Asad Toor gained substantial traction, with their updates particularly resonating with PTI supporters. Lawyer Abdul Moiz Jaferi noted that just three vlogs by Matiullah and Toor amassed over a million views in 24 hours. Other vloggers accompanying PTI rallies also attracted significant followings for real-time updates.
In contrast, mainstream electronic media faced criticism for favoring the government's narrative. Analysts Absa Komal and Arifa Noor highlighted the bias, with Noor likening the coverage to the PTV days, where only the government's perspective dominated. Journalist Hamid Mir, in an interview with VOA, criticized the media for failing to report PTI supporters reaching D-Chowk, noting that such updates came from social media instead.
Observers also pointed out a clear divide: YouTubers were on the ground, while mainstream media largely operated from their offices. If Matiullah Jan and Asad Toor were seen as sympathetic to the protests, journalists like Absar Alam and Talat Hussain were unequivocal in their opposition.
An editorial in Dawn on Wednesday called out the starkly partisan coverage, noting, "On social media, partisan 'analysts' and opinion makers competed for attention, with one side portraying the events as a revolution while the other celebrated reports of army intervention with shoot-on-sight orders."
Reporting on PTI leaders leaving Islamabad also drew criticism. Daily Jang accused the leaders of fleeing "with their tails between their legs," while VOA described them as having "escaped." Journalists Tahir Khan and Ahmed Noorani condemned such framing, calling for integrity in media reporting.
The protests were marred by violence against journalists, with Dawn reporting that dozens of alleged PTI supporters attacked an Associated Press videographer, causing head injuries and stealing his equipment. The incident underscored the dangers faced by media professionals during political turmoil.
Opinions on the aftermath of the protest varied widely. Dawn columnist Farooq Nadeem Paracha posted a photo of a clean D-Chowk with the caption "khatamshud" (finished), while journalist Tariq Mateen expressed sorrow over the violence and loss of lives.
January 17, 2025: In an unprecedented breach of judicial protocol, Pakistani journalists accurately revealed Imran Khan's 14-year sentence in the Al-Qadir case on social media 24 hours before the official verdict, raising serious questions about court independence
January 17, 2025: Geo News faces backlash for insensitive coverage of Saif Ali Khan’s stabbing, airing Bollywood song clips before announcing the tragic news
January 17, 2025: An in-depth analysis of ARY News' false reporting on Imran Khan's verdict and the broader crisis of unverified news in Pakistani electronic media, exploring solutions for responsible journalism.
January 16, 2025: The FIA has registered cases against five individuals, including journalist Imran Riaz Khan and PTI leader Shahbaz Gill, for sharing defamatory AI-generated content targeting the UAE President and Punjab Chief Minister. How does this reflect on Pakistan-UAE relations and the misuse of AI?
January 13, 2025: An analysis of Absar Alam's controversial criticism of successful Pakistani YouTubers in exile, examining the intersection of journalism, digital media success, and political persecution, while questioning the credibility of criticism from a former PEMRA chief whose own appointment was declared illegal.
January 13, 2025: Prominent journalist Asma Shirazi faces relentless online harassment in a coordinated campaign involving gendered disinformation. Press freedom groups demand immediate action to protect female journalists in Pakistan.
January 10, 2025: The FIA Cyber Wing is investigating a social media campaign involving AI-manipulated images of Maryam Nawaz and UAE President Mohammed bin Zayed. Teams are working to trace the content's origins and identify those involved.
January 05, 2025: JournalismPakistan.com welcomes renowned cricket historian and broadcaster Dr. Nauman Niaz as sports editor, bringing his extensive experience in cricket journalism, broadcasting, and scholarly work to strengthen the platform's sports coverage.
January 16, 2025 Explore the evolution of the ICC Champions Trophy and cricket’s commercialization journey, from a gentleman’s game to a global enterprise. Discover how the ICC balanced tradition with revenue generation.
January 12, 2025 Explore an in-depth analysis of Pakistan cricket's decline in Test matches, examining systemic failures, cultural challenges, and the urgent need for modernization. From mismanagement of talents like Babar Azam and Shaheen Afridi to resistance against technological advancement, this comprehensive piece investigates how a cricket powerhouse finds itself at a critical crossroads between tradition and progress.
January 09, 2025 Shan Masood's magnificent 145 and a record-breaking opening stand with Babar Azam highlighted Pakistan's valiant fight against South Africa in Cape Town. Despite their resilience, Pakistan fell short, reflecting on deeper cricketing issues.
January 05, 2025 An in-depth analysis of Virat Kohli's recent struggles in Test cricket, examining his technical changes, statistical decline since 2021, and the broader implications for his legacy as one of cricket's greatest batsmen. The article explores whether this is a temporary setback or signals the twilight of an extraordinary career.
January 05, 2025 Pulitzer Prize-winning Washington Post cartoonist Ann Telnaes resigns after her cartoon depicting media moguls, including Post owner Jeff Bezos, kneeling before Donald Trump was rejected, sparking debate about editorial independence and press freedom.