JournalismPakistan.com | Published November 18, 2018
Join our WhatsApp channel
The White House agreed on Friday to allow CNN reporter Jim Acosta (pictured) back in after a judge ruled that the star journalist was improperly banned following a testy exchange at a press conference with President Donald Trump.
Trump spokeswoman Sarah Sanders said: “in response to the court, we will temporarily reinstate the reporter’s hard pass.” But she left open the possibility of seeking to remove Acosta’s access later and said new rules would be imposed “to ensure fair and orderly press conferences.”
Trump said that “rules and regulations” were being drafted to govern such gatherings, where the president or his representatives often accuse journalists —Acosta in particular — of being overly hostile.
“We have to practice decorum. We want total freedom of the press,” Trump told reporters, adding later in an interview with Fox News: “If he misbehaves, we’ll throw him out.” In fact, Trump himself frequently speaks harshly to reporters, for example, last week telling another CNN correspondent several times that her question was “stupid.”
He also routinely describes journalists he does not approve of, and the media in general, as “enemies of the people.”
Acosta often aggressively questions the White House on its attitude toward journalists and has been criticized even by some in the media for becoming part of the story he is meant to be covering.
On Nov. 7, the day he was stripped of his pass, Acosta had riled Trump by refusing to give up the microphone at a news conference when he considered that Trump was evading his question. Trump responded by branding Acosta a “rude, terrible person.”
CNN cast the controversy as a question of free speech, which is protected under the constitution’s first amendment.
In his ruling Friday, Judge Timothy Kelly stressed that he had only found the procedure for expelling Acosta illegal and that free speech did not enter the equation. “I want to be very clear that I have not determined that the First Amendment was violated,” he said in the Washington courtroom, adding that further hearings would be held on that aspect.
The U.S. Justice Department’s lawyer, James Burnham, argued that Acosta had “disrupted” last week’s news conference and that “there is no First Amendment right to access the White House.” However, major media outlets took up Acosta’s cause. Tellingly, Trump’s most friendly outlet, Fox News, joined the suit calling for Acosta’s pass to be returned.
“We are gratified with this result and we look forward to a full resolution in the coming days,” CNN said in a statement. “Our sincere thanks to all who have supported not just CNN, but a free, strong and independent American press.”
Shortly after the ruling, Acosta returned to the White House, telling fellow journalists that “this was a test.”
“Journalists need to know that their First Amendment rights are sacred,” he said.
The spat over Acosta has prompted an unusually public show of unity between America’s powerful media organizations. Those backing CNN’s court action included the Associated Press, Bloomberg, First Look Media Works, Gannett, the National Press Club Journalism Institute, NBC News, The New York Times, Politico, Press Freedom Defense Fund, EW Scripps Company, USA Today and The Washington Post.
“Whether the news of the day concerns national security, the economy or the environment, reporters covering the White House must remain free to ask questions,” the media groups said in a joint statement.
After the judge’s ruling, the White House Correspondents’ Association President, Olivier Knox, cheered a decision that “made it clear that the White House cannot arbitrarily revoke a White House press pass.”
“We thank all of the news outlets and individual reporters who stood up in recent days for the vital role a free and independent news media plays in our republic,” he said. - AFP
January 13, 2025: An analysis of Absar Alam's controversial criticism of successful Pakistani YouTubers in exile, examining the intersection of journalism, digital media success, and political persecution, while questioning the credibility of criticism from a former PEMRA chief whose own appointment was declared illegal.
January 13, 2025: Prominent journalist Asma Shirazi faces relentless online harassment in a coordinated campaign involving gendered disinformation. Press freedom groups demand immediate action to protect female journalists in Pakistan.
January 10, 2025: The FIA Cyber Wing is investigating a social media campaign involving AI-manipulated images of Maryam Nawaz and UAE President Mohammed bin Zayed. Teams are working to trace the content's origins and identify those involved.
January 05, 2025: JournalismPakistan.com welcomes renowned cricket historian and broadcaster Dr. Nauman Niaz as sports editor, bringing his extensive experience in cricket journalism, broadcasting, and scholarly work to strengthen the platform's sports coverage.
January 01, 2025: Trump envoy Richard Grenell's sudden week-long silence on Pakistan and Imran Khan raises questions after fierce Twitter battles with journalists and politicians. From explosive exchanges to mysterious quiet - what's behind the digital retreat?
December 31, 2024: Year-end report by Pakistan Press Foundation reveals severe challenges to press freedom in Pakistan, highlighting violence against journalists, internet shutdowns, and restrictive policies in 2024.
December 30, 2024: Remembering Arshad A. Zuberi, the deputy chief executive of Business Recorder Group, who passed away on Sunday after a protracted illness, leaving behind a remarkable legacy in journalism.
December 29, 2024: Veteran journalist Nusrat Javeed has accused PTI of operating a bot in Richard Grenell’s name, fueling a Twitter controversy amid the Trump aide’s vocal support for Imran Khan.
January 12, 2025 Explore an in-depth analysis of Pakistan cricket's decline in Test matches, examining systemic failures, cultural challenges, and the urgent need for modernization. From mismanagement of talents like Babar Azam and Shaheen Afridi to resistance against technological advancement, this comprehensive piece investigates how a cricket powerhouse finds itself at a critical crossroads between tradition and progress.
January 09, 2025 Shan Masood's magnificent 145 and a record-breaking opening stand with Babar Azam highlighted Pakistan's valiant fight against South Africa in Cape Town. Despite their resilience, Pakistan fell short, reflecting on deeper cricketing issues.
January 05, 2025 An in-depth analysis of Virat Kohli's recent struggles in Test cricket, examining his technical changes, statistical decline since 2021, and the broader implications for his legacy as one of cricket's greatest batsmen. The article explores whether this is a temporary setback or signals the twilight of an extraordinary career.
January 05, 2025 Pulitzer Prize-winning Washington Post cartoonist Ann Telnaes resigns after her cartoon depicting media moguls, including Post owner Jeff Bezos, kneeling before Donald Trump was rejected, sparking debate about editorial independence and press freedom.
January 03, 2025 Explore the poignant narrative of cricket's fallen captains, focusing on Rohit Sharma's Test career crisis and its parallels with legendary leaders Kim Hughes, Ian Botham, and Steve Waugh. A deep dive into cricket's most tragic leadership endings.