JournalismPakistan.com | Published January 28, 2025 at 05:10 pm | JP Staff Report
Join our WhatsApp channel
ISLAMABAD—On Tuesday, the Senate of Pakistan passed the Pakistan Electronic Crimes Act (PECA) Amendments Bill, triggering widespread condemnation and protests from journalist unions, media watchdogs, and civil society. It marked yet another grim chapter for a media landscape already grappling with stifling censorship.
Prominent journalist Mohammad Malick described the moment poignantly in a tweet: “After Digital Nation bill, Senate passes PECA amendment Act in mere 15 minutes. Free Speech died in Pakistan today.” Highlighting the draconian nature of the legislation, he warned, “Nobody, forget just journalists, will be able to think or speak freely anymore.” Malick’s tweet underscored the fear that these laws—typically the hallmark of authoritarian regimes—are now being championed by the government, a trend he denounced as a betrayal of democratic principles.
Absa Komal, an anchor at DawnNews, called it a “Black day for freedom of speech & expression in Pakistan,” emphasizing that journalist bodies are united in their fight against the amendments in courts. Meanwhile, the Freedom Network described the moment as “a dark chapter in history” and lamented that the amended law would criminalize even legitimate criticism of elected officials.
Sweeping Powers, Severe Penalties
The PECA amendments introduce a Social Media Protection and Regulatory Authority with unprecedented powers to control digital communication. This Authority, strategically staffed with government appointees such as the Interior Secretary and PTA Chairman, is designed to operate as an extension of the state rather than as an independent regulatory body. It effectively weaponizes the law against free expression, granting the government unchecked power to monitor, regulate, and penalize.
The legislation criminalizes vaguely defined “fake news,” imposing penalties of up to three years in prison and fines of Rs 2 million. This ambiguous framing is a dangerous precedent, enabling the state to target legitimate journalism and critical commentary under the pretext of combating misinformation.
Moreover, the law’s provision for a 24-hour complaint resolution window and broad powers to remove content suggests a systemic approach to silencing dissent. These mechanisms appear calculated to suppress digital activism, investigative reporting, and political criticism—hallmarks of a healthy democratic society.
Nationwide Protests and Press Walkouts
Journalists in the Senate’s press gallery staged a walkout as the bill was introduced, echoing scenes from last week when the amendments were passed by the National Assembly. The Pakistan Federal Union of Journalists (PFUJ) has outrightly rejected the amendments, calling them the “blackest law” in the nation’s democratic history. The PFUJ mobilized nationwide protests to demand the bill’s withdrawal.
The legislation’s passage has further united journalist bodies and civil society in their resolve to fight back. As Komal tweeted, the draconian amendments could ignite a long-overdue nationwide movement for press freedom.
Implications for Pakistan’s Global Standing
By enacting such restrictive legislation, Pakistan risks severe international backlash. The PECA amendments could lead to diplomatic consequences, further decline in global press freedom rankings, and reputational damage on the world stage. These laws also threaten to stifle digital innovation and activism, creating a heavily surveilled and controlled environment that stands in stark opposition to the principles of free expression and democratic transparency.
A Calculated Tool of Repression
The PECA Amendment is more than a media regulation bill. It is a calculated instrument of political repression designed to preemptively silence dissent. In an era where digital platforms have become vital tools for accountability and activism, such laws are a deliberate move to curb public discourse and preserve the status quo.
The Senate’s actions have underscored a disturbing trend of eroding freedoms in Pakistan. As journalist Mohammad Malick aptly put it, “Shame on this government, and shame on everyone who helped to pass these laws.” It remains to be seen whether the judiciary or public pressure can overturn this legislative assault on press freedom. For now, however, Pakistan’s media and civil society face an uphill battle to reclaim their right to free speech.
March 20, 2025: The FIA has arrested journalist and Raftar founder Farhan Mallick over his YouTube content, sparking concerns over press freedom. His family and media organizations demand transparency and his immediate release.
March 20, 2025: A Pakistani delegation, including journalists and filmmakers, secretly visited Israel, sparking controversy. The visit, facilitated by Israeli NGO Sharaka, aimed to promote cultural diplomacy. Read more on this developing story.
March 20, 2025: Amnesty International calls for an investigation into the enforced disappearance of journalist Ahmad Noorani’s brothers, condemning it as an attack on press freedom and human rights.
March 19, 2025: Islamabad Police deny raiding journalist Ahmad Noorani’s residence as his family files a complaint about the alleged abduction of his brothers. Noorani, residing in the US, claims his family was targeted due to his reporting.
March 19, 2025: The reported abduction of investigative journalist Ahmed Noorani's brothers marks a disturbing escalation in Pakistan's press freedom crisis, following his exposé on military leadership privileges.
March 16, 2025: Senior analyst Imtiaz Gul joins the growing list of journalists and commentators banned from Pakistani television, raising fresh concerns about declining press freedom in the country.
March 14, 2025: Explore how exiled Pakistani journalists are leveraging digital platforms to deliver independent analysis and fill critical information gaps that state-controlled media leaves behind, transforming the country's media landscape from abroad.
March 07, 2025: The Supreme Court of Pakistan has questioned the delay in the Arshad Sharif murder investigation, as the government seeks additional time to finalize a mutual legal assistance agreement with Kenya.
March 19, 2025 Apply for the NYU Stern Climate Economics Journalism Fellowship to deepen your understanding of climate economics and its impact on global finance. Applications close on April 20, 2025.
March 16, 2025 The Trump administration has ordered furloughs at U.S.-funded broadcasters, including Voice of America (VOA) and Radio Free Asia, raising concerns about press freedom and government control over media funding.
March 15, 2025 Explore the dynamic relationship between athletes and sports journalists, examining the challenges, ethical dilemmas, and mutual benefits that shape the sports media landscape.
March 14, 2025 The National Press Foundation is offering a fully funded journalism training workshop in Singapore from June 22 to 25. The workshop will cover sustainable global trade, investment, politics, and more. Apply by April 6.
March 14, 2025 The Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ) urges Maharashtra authorities to ensure their AI-driven media monitoring plan does not undermine press freedom. The initiative, which classifies news as positive or negative, raises concerns over government overreach and self-censorship.