Press freedom under relentless pressure Baishakhi TV staff allege attack, editor detained RIUJ urges AJK to remove journalist from Fourth Schedule Veteran journalist Hussain Naqi dies in Lahore Quetta court rejects journalist Shahid Maitla's bail When a newsroom banned JournalismPakistan The JournalismPakistan Global Media Brief | Edition 47 | November 20, 2026 Islamabad's journalists face an invisible digital battle Judge allows Trump's $15bn New York Times lawsuit to proceed China bars Bloomberg journalist from Trump-Xi-Putin meeting Who is counting Pakistan's journalists? Karachi court frames charges against Iqrar ul Hassan An American news website and its invisible journalists Swat journalist Malik Quwat Khan injured in attack McClatchy outlines AI-led overhaul after newsroom cuts Press freedom under relentless pressure Baishakhi TV staff allege attack, editor detained RIUJ urges AJK to remove journalist from Fourth Schedule Veteran journalist Hussain Naqi dies in Lahore Quetta court rejects journalist Shahid Maitla's bail When a newsroom banned JournalismPakistan The JournalismPakistan Global Media Brief | Edition 47 | November 20, 2026 Islamabad's journalists face an invisible digital battle Judge allows Trump's $15bn New York Times lawsuit to proceed China bars Bloomberg journalist from Trump-Xi-Putin meeting Who is counting Pakistan's journalists? Karachi court frames charges against Iqrar ul Hassan An American news website and its invisible journalists Swat journalist Malik Quwat Khan injured in attack McClatchy outlines AI-led overhaul after newsroom cuts
Logo
Janu
World

Our army is not the enemy

 JournalismPakistan.com |  Published: 2 September 2012 |  Stephen Manuel

Join our WhatsApp channel

Our army is not the enemy
The article discusses the media's responsibility in covering sensitive topics, particularly regarding the army and Taliban. It emphasizes the need for ethical journalism and accountability within media houses.

ISLAMABAD: A little over a year ago and then again earlier this year news channels in the country came under scrutiny and criticism for showing graphic and gory content despite all the major media houses agreeing that such material would not be telecast and despite their being a regulatory code of conduct in place.

It may or may not work, but to a certain extent it acts as a deterrent. Now, it appears newspapers in the country too need to have such a code in place. I’m not talking about censorship or self-censorship… just common sense. One is forced to wonder what that largely ineffective and political body, the All Pakistan Newspapers Society (APNS), and that other den of conspirators and third-class so-called media persons, the Pakistan Federal Union of Journalists (PFUJ), do with their ‘elected’ authority.

Also one is forced to seriously question the caliber of the management, editorial staff and decision makers in our media houses and TV channels as well as their ideological bent.

It is not only confusing but alarming. If the fifth pillar of the nation cannot be objective and loyal to the country, then who?

The graphic photographs in The Nation and Pakistan Today of Pakistani soldiers beheaded by the Taliban the other day was more than a little disturbing to say the least.

Imagine setting your eyes on those horrific images of the slain soldiers and their detached heads at the breakfast table or perhaps getting to your office and discovering the same looking up at you from your desk or work station.

How can it be justified?

Was it an error of judgment?

Was it sheer incompetence?

Or was it a willful and deliberate decision? If it was an error of judgment then it would be a collective one for which the management, the editorial staff, and most certainly the editor, the night editor, news editor and the chief sub should be held responsible.

With authority comes responsibility and quite obviously none was displayed in this particular case. This in itself speaks volumes for the men who took the decision to feature those photographs. It shows up their caliber and lack of professional sense.

In any media house worth its name, heads would roll. Indeed should roll. But of course such a culture is not ours. Nor is the culture of taking responsibility and resigning. We rather point fingers and reflect the blame than owe up to our mistake. That is us and our media culture.

A point in case would be Dunya TV’s controversial Lucqman-Bukhari-Malik interview, no to mention all the mudslinging by so-called giants like Najam Sethi and Talat Hussain.

If the decision was caused by sheer incompetence, a scenario tying in with the error of judgment scenario, it is even more shameful. What the heck was the management thinking of appointing such people to top positions. Journalism does not come easy; it is not a place for pretenders. Such people are always exposed.

Here too our culture of appointing friends and friends’ friends, relatives and family members comes into play. Journalism is a profession, not the extension of one’s social circle.

In this case too, if incompetence or lack of professional savoir faire were to blame, accountability must be taken, starting from the very top.

An apology will not do. It’s not enough. It shows a certain shallowness and insincerity. It shows lack of remorse.

And finally, if those pictures appeared because of a deliberate decision then we certainly have reason to worry. If those pictures were there because of either personal or collective ideological and political motives, then we should be really concerned… indeed very wary and afraid.

For in such a case all professionalism and the governing ethics of journalism were willfully tossed out the window. It makes the fifth pillar of the nation redundant; is would not be a pillar, but the pretense of one, a mere prop… and a shaky one at that too.

I’m not a big fan of the army. I’m also not against it. That does not mean I would take pleasure in the death of its soldiers. Those soldiers are sons of the soil. They stand between us and danger. They lay down their lives for us and they fight for us. When push comes to shove, they are all that stands between us and the enemy.

They have families, mothers, fathers, brothers, sisters and children. They laugh like us and they cry like us and they are Muslims. They are human.

Do a few disgruntled and misled so called journalists have the right to question the ability or integrity of the army or its soldiers?

If these persons believe the Taliban are right and the army is the enemy, then they do not belong in a newspaper office. They need to be with their terrorist brethren.

By featuring such pictures or stories, such persons in the newsroom and TV channels are misleading the populace into believing the Taliban are right and the army is wrong. They are eulogizing the Taliban and they are demonstrating that the army is weak and not up to the task of facing the Taliban.

If this is the case and it is allowed or encouraged by the media houses and print and electronic media managements, there is indeed a cause to worry for then it means that the ideology and belief of the nation has taken a serious turn for the worse and is being voiced and reflected through the media.

It also means the media and all it stands for has been compromised.

The army may not be everybody’s friend, but it is also not the enemy.

Key Points

  • Criticism of graphic content in Pakistani media.
  • Call for accountability among media personnel.
  • Concerns about the portrayal of the army and Taliban.
  • Questioning the ideological motives behind media portrayals.
  • Emphasis on the humanity of soldiers and their sacrifices.

Ask AI: Understand this story your way

AI Enabled

Dig deeper, ask anything — get instant context, background, and clarity.

Not sure what to choose? Try one of these.

The AI generates results based on your selected options
Your AI-generated results will appear here after you click the button.

Disclaimer: This feature is powered by AI and is intended to help readers explore and understand news stories more easily. While we strive for accuracy, AI-generated responses may occasionally be incomplete or reflect limitations in the underlying model. This feature does not represent the editorial views of JournalismPakistan. For our full, verified reporting, please refer to the original article.

Dive Deeper

When a newsroom banned JournalismPakistan

When a newsroom banned JournalismPakistan

 November 21, 2026: JournalismPakistan launches From the JP Archives, a new weekly series revisiting its media reporting history. The first edition recalls how a Peshawar newspaper bureau blocked access to the website in June 2012.

Who is counting Pakistan's journalists?

Who is counting Pakistan's journalists?

 November 20, 2026: JournalismPakistan investigates conflicting estimates of how many journalists work in Pakistan, revealing gaps in records that affect welfare and safety.

Who really controls Pakistan's newsrooms?

Who really controls Pakistan's newsrooms?

 November 17, 2026: Pakistan's newsrooms are shaped by owners, advertisers, regulators, political actors and state institutions, raising doubts about editors' independence.

Newsroom
Press freedom under relentless pressure

Press freedom under relentless pressure

 November 22, 2026 Tracker shows growing threats to press freedom - arrests, legal harassment, violence and administrative controls - alongside a few court wins and newsroom pushback.


Baishakhi TV staff allege attack, editor detained

Baishakhi TV staff allege attack, editor detained

 November 22, 2026 Baishakhi TV staff allege an attack on their Dhaka office as police take editor Tipu Alam Milon into custody; accounts of the confrontation differ.


RIUJ urges AJK to remove journalist from Fourth Schedule

RIUJ urges AJK to remove journalist from Fourth Schedule

 November 22, 2026 The Rawalpindi Islamabad Union of Journalists urged the AJK government to remove Soban Iftikhar Raja from the Fourth Schedule, warning the listing could undermine press freedom and discourage independent reporting.


Quetta court rejects journalist Shahid Maitla's bail

Quetta court rejects journalist Shahid Maitla's bail

 November 21, 2026 A Quetta magistrate denied senior journalist Shahid Maitla's bail in a PECA defamation case; he remains in Quetta Jail as PFUJ leaders consult lawyers.


The JournalismPakistan Global Media Brief | Edition 47 | November 20, 2026

The JournalismPakistan Global Media Brief | Edition 47 | November 20, 2026

 November 20, 2026 Global media brief highlights growing threats to independent journalism from legal, political and financial pressures, plus violence and AI-driven newsroom upheavals.


Popular Stories