Stakeholders demand meaningful consultation for Internet governance in Pakistan

 JournalismPakistan.com |  Published December 05, 2024 at 08:57 pm |  Media Release

ISLAMABAD—Pakistan is the 7th-largest population of internet users in the world having more than 138 million users of 3G/4G internet users. Millions use several digital platforms for multiple purposes including access to and sharing information. However, the majority remains absent from the discussion and debate for an enabling environment for public discourse on freedom of expression, access to online information, and governance reforms in digital media platforms of Pakistan.  

This was highlighted during a multi-stakeholder national consultation, jointly organized by UNESCO and the Institute for Research, Advocacy and Development (IRADA), to formalize a constructive dialogue on UNESCO Guidelines for the governance of digital platforms to create a conducive environment for public discourse on freedom of expression, access to online information and governance reforms in digital media platforms. The participants highlighted the need for digital and information literacy/ MIL and collective actions for the realization of digital rights in the country.  

The national consultation was inaugurated by Antony Kar Hung Tam, Officer-in-Charge, UNESCO Office in Pakistan. While delivering his inaugural speech, Mr. Antony Kar Hung Tam emphasized that there is an urgent need to tackle disinformation and harmful content online while safeguarding fundamental rights, particularly freedom of expression and access to information. "To achieve this balance, shared responsibilities and collaborative efforts from all stakeholders is needed."

Chief guest for the national consultation, Muhammad Shahzad, Director General, Centre of Digital Communication, Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, Pakistan, said that balancing hate speech and disinformation with legitimate discourse should be an utmost priority for stakeholders. Ahmed Shamim Pirzada, Director General of the Web Analysis Division at PTA also gave opening remarks at the event and stressed how concerns around digital governance are a global issue and not just limited to Pakistan, which is why we must work together to find solutions.  

The national consultation aimed at forging a multistakeholder advocacy forum to advocate for the implementation of the recommendations collected through the provincial consultations, along with developing an evidence-based approach to carve out a path for global dialogues complemented by regional-specific concerns on the governance of digital platforms.  

The national consultation was preceded by four provincial consultations that helped collate recommendations from various stakeholders for the governance of digital media platforms in Pakistan with respect to internet freedom, human rights, access to information that were further discussed and refined in the national level consultation.

Through these multi-stakeholders consultations, UNESCO and IRADA have also collected stakeholders-wise recommendations and developed a roadmap for effective implementation of the Guidelines for the Governance of Digital Platforms, enabling the environment for the exercise of fundamental freedoms and digital rights of citizens.  
The UNESCO Guidelines for Governance of Digital Platforms emphasize the need for an enabling environment to safeguard freedom of expression, access to information, and other human rights while ensuring a safe and open digital space. The guidelines outline the roles of various stakeholders: states must respect and protect human rights, digital platforms should uphold human rights, and intergovernmental organizations, civil society, media, academia, and the technical community also play crucial roles. The guidelines propose a multistakeholder, human rights-based approach to platform governance, incorporating self-regulatory, co-regulatory, and statutory mechanisms. The guidelines also highlight media and information literacy and respect for cultural diversity as shared responsibilities and recommend that platforms have processes for content moderation, risk assessment, and accountability.

Representatives from academia, civil society, digital media, and journalists, discussed and presented recommendations for a national-level regulatory framework that aligns with the UNESCO Guidelines. These recommendations included increased cooperation between stakeholders, promotion of enhancing media and information literacy, call for better content moderation and curation by digital media platforms. The presentations were followed by a panel discussion that explored these recommendations in detail.

'Who will be responsible if my sons are harmed?' mother pleads in court

 March 24, 2025:  Who will be responsible if my sons are harmed?" cries a mother in Islamabad High Court, pleading for justice after her sons' alleged abduction. The court summons the IG police over the alleged kidnapping. The family claims intelligence agencies are involved.

Puppet Press: How Pakistan's media sold its soul to the highest bidder

 March 24, 2025:  Explore the 10 critical reasons why Pakistan's legacy media continues to disappoint, from political bias and corporate influence to digital transition failures and unsustainable business models in Pakistani journalism.

State as judge: Dawn criticizes Farhan Mallick’s arrest under PECA

 March 22, 2025:  The arrest of journalist and Raftar founder Farhan Mallick under PECA violations has sparked concerns over press freedom in Pakistan. Digital rights activists warn of increasing state suppression.

Outrage as Geo security guards attack workers protesting unpaid wages

 March 21, 2025:  Geo Group’s security guards allegedly led an assault on protesting journalists in Islamabad, dismantling their camp and threatening them. The hypocrisy of a media giant advocating press freedom while suppressing its workers is exposed.

CPJ urges Pakistan to reveal whereabouts of missing journalist and Noorani's brothers

 March 21, 2025:  CPJ demands Pakistani authorities reveal the whereabouts of journalist Asif Karim Khehtran and the abducted brothers of US-based journalist Ahmad Noorani, condemning the ongoing media crackdown.

FIA arrests journalist Farhan Mallick over YouTube content

 March 20, 2025:  The FIA has arrested journalist and Raftar founder Farhan Mallick over his YouTube content, sparking concerns over press freedom. His family and media organizations demand transparency and his immediate release.

Pakistan delegation's secret visit to Israel sparks controversy

 March 20, 2025:  A Pakistani delegation, including journalists and filmmakers, secretly visited Israel, sparking controversy. The visit, facilitated by Israeli NGO Sharaka, aimed to promote cultural diplomacy. Read more on this developing story.

Amnesty International urges safe return of journalist Ahmad Noorani’s brothers

 March 20, 2025:  Amnesty International calls for an investigation into the enforced disappearance of journalist Ahmad Noorani’s brothers, condemning it as an attack on press freedom and human rights.