Fact-checking failure: How Hamid Mir and Asma Shirazi fell for an AI-generated hoax

 JournalismPakistan.com |  Published August 24, 2024 at 09:02 pm |  JP Staff Report

ISLAMABAD—In an era where misinformation spreads like wildfire, the responsibility of journalists to verify information before sharing it has never been more critical. Recently, two of Pakistan's most prominent journalists, Hamid Mir and Asma Shirazi, were embroiled in controversy after sharing an AI-generated fake image on social media. The incident raises serious concerns about journalistic integrity and the dangers of unverified information in the digital age.

The image in question depicted Natasha, a woman involved in a tragic accident case in Karachi, making a "victory" sign outside what appeared to be a court. The implication was clear: the accused, despite being responsible for the deaths of a 60-year-old man and his daughter, was flaunting her release. The outrage was immediate, with both journalists expressing their dismay at the perceived miscarriage of justice.

However, it was soon revealed that the image was a complete fabrication, created using artificial intelligence. The supposed scene was a figment of technology, not reality. Both Hamid Mir and Asma Shirazi deleted their posts, but the damage was done. The quick spread of the fake image and its endorsement by respected media figures highlighted the pervasive issue of misinformation and the ease with which it can ensnare even seasoned journalists.

This incident underscores the need for journalists to adhere to strict verification protocols, especially when sharing content on social media platforms. The failure to do so not only undermines their credibility but also contributes to the larger problem of fake news, which can have far-reaching consequences in shaping public opinion and influencing events.

Hamid Mir and Asma Shirazi's swift deletion of the posts suggests an acknowledgment of their mistake, but it also raises questions about the initial lack of due diligence. In an industry where credibility is paramount, such lapses can have long-term repercussions.

This incident should serve as a wake-up call for journalists everywhere. The rise of AI-generated content means that the traditional tools of verification are more important than ever. Before hitting "share," journalists must ensure that what they are endorsing is rooted in fact, not fiction. The role of the media as the fourth estate depends on its ability to hold power to account—something that is impossible if the media itself falls prey to the very misinformation it seeks to combat.

Freedom of expression shrinks in Pakistan as PECA Amendments take toll: report

 April 30, 2025:  Freedom of expression in Pakistan is under threat, as the 2025 Freedom Network report reveals increased arrests, censorship, and legal restrictions following amendments to PECA, posing serious risks to journalists and democratic values.

Dawn urges Indian media to abandon war rhetoric

 April 30, 2025:  Dawn has criticized the Indian media's calls for war and condemned the banning of 16 Pakistani YouTube channels, urging a rational response after the Pahalgam attack that left 26 dead.

India bans 16 Pakistani YouTube channels following Pahalgan attack

 April 28, 2025:  India has banned 16 Pakistani YouTube channels, including major news outlets and individual journalists, following the deadly Pahalgam attack. Tensions escalate as Islamabad demands a neutral probe.

Coordinated or coincidence? Identical tweets by Pakistani journalists raise eyebrows

 April 23, 2025:  Pakistani journalists respond in unison to a post hinting at a possible Indian military strike. Citing the 2019 ‘Swift Retort,’ they warn of a stronger response if provoked again.

Sher Afzal Marwat launches personal attacks on journalists after PTI expulsion

 April 21, 2025:  After being expelled from PTI, MNA Sher Afzal Marwat launches personal attacks on journalists and Aleema Khan, sparking outrage on social media over his offensive remarks.

Journalist Sanaullah Khan alleges FIA blocking accounts of YouTubers and families

 April 21, 2025:  Journalist Sanaullah Khan reveals that the FIA has launched a financial crackdown on YouTubers by freezing the bank accounts of journalists and their family members—raising serious concerns over freedom of expression and legal process.

A launch in style: Dr. Nauman Niaz unveils 'In A Different Realm'

 April 20, 2025:  Dr. Nauman Niaz launched his fifteenth book, In A Different Realm: Story of Quadruple and Triple Centuries 1876–2025, at an elegant Islamabad event, reflecting on cricket’s rarest feats and his journey as a scholar of the game.

Sindhi journalist AD Shar brutally murdered, PFUJ declares three-day mourning

 April 11, 2025:  Sindhi journalist AD Shar was brutally murdered in Khairpur, Sindh. His body was found dumped on Handiyari Link Road. PFUJ has declared a three-day mourning period and demanded justice.