Asma Shirazi hits back, calling Moeed Pirzada's criticism 'political hypocrisy'

 JournalismPakistan.com |  Published November 09, 2024 at 05:19 pm

ISLAMABAD—A social media clash between prominent journalists Asma Shirazi and Moeed Pirzada has stirred debate within Pakistan's media landscape, spotlighting the polarized views over democracy, journalistic ethics, and freedom of expression.

In a recent video, Moeed Pirzada, a Pakistani journalist currently living in exile, expressed his disapproval of Shirazi's enthusiastic response to news of deportations involving Pakistani protesters in the UK. These protesters had chanted slogans against Pakistan's Chief Justice Qazi Faiz Esa, a move that Pirzada believes reflects the protesters' democratic right to freedom of expression. He criticized Shirazi's reaction, which he perceived as supportive of the deportations, alleging that it revealed her "disregard for democratic values and freedom of protest."

Pirzada pointed to Shirazi's choice of words and expressions on her television show, noting that her enthusiasm and description of the deportations as a "very good development" hinted at her bias against the protesters. He went on to suggest that Shirazi's views imply an endorsement of recent rulings by the Chief Justice, which, according to Pirzada, have undermined Pakistan's democratic principles and judicial independence. He urged Shirazi to reflect on her perspective and consider the broader implications of suppressing democratic freedoms.

However, Shirazi was quick to hit back, sharing a response that delved into what she described as Pirzada's "political hypocrisy." In a fiery statement in Urdu, Shirazi alleged that Pirzada, whom she accused of previously serving the establishment, was now preaching about freedom and democracy from a flawed position. "Is there a bigger example of social fascism than a fake person giving sermons on journalism and humanity, a man accused of forging his deceased father's signature for inheritance?" she remarked. Shirazi expressed disappointment that the opposition party, Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI), had tweeted in support of Pirzada's stance, a move she interpreted as an endorsement of his views.

Shirazi further criticized Pirzada's past associations, calling him a "mouthpiece for the establishment" who had no standing to label her as an "establishment pawn." She referenced Pirzada's past conduct in Pakistani media, where she alleged he aligned closely with powerful institutions and criticized the very actions he now claimed to defend. "It's ironic that those who were beneficiaries of the hybrid regime now accuse others of hypocrisy," Shirazi added, challenging Pirzada's credibility.

Shirazi voiced her frustration over what she termed "political double standards" by Pirzada and his supporters, lamenting the state of political discourse and the impact of divisive rhetoric on Pakistan's democratic values.

'Who will be responsible if my sons are harmed?' mother pleads in court

 March 24, 2025:  Who will be responsible if my sons are harmed?" cries a mother in Islamabad High Court, pleading for justice after her sons' alleged abduction. The court summons the IG police over the alleged kidnapping. The family claims intelligence agencies are involved.

Puppet Press: How Pakistan's media sold its soul to the highest bidder

 March 24, 2025:  Explore the 10 critical reasons why Pakistan's legacy media continues to disappoint, from political bias and corporate influence to digital transition failures and unsustainable business models in Pakistani journalism.

State as judge: Dawn criticizes Farhan Mallick’s arrest under PECA

 March 22, 2025:  The arrest of journalist and Raftar founder Farhan Mallick under PECA violations has sparked concerns over press freedom in Pakistan. Digital rights activists warn of increasing state suppression.

Outrage as Geo security guards attack workers protesting unpaid wages

 March 21, 2025:  Geo Group’s security guards allegedly led an assault on protesting journalists in Islamabad, dismantling their camp and threatening them. The hypocrisy of a media giant advocating press freedom while suppressing its workers is exposed.

CPJ urges Pakistan to reveal whereabouts of missing journalist and Noorani's brothers

 March 21, 2025:  CPJ demands Pakistani authorities reveal the whereabouts of journalist Asif Karim Khehtran and the abducted brothers of US-based journalist Ahmad Noorani, condemning the ongoing media crackdown.

FIA arrests journalist Farhan Mallick over YouTube content

 March 20, 2025:  The FIA has arrested journalist and Raftar founder Farhan Mallick over his YouTube content, sparking concerns over press freedom. His family and media organizations demand transparency and his immediate release.

Pakistan delegation's secret visit to Israel sparks controversy

 March 20, 2025:  A Pakistani delegation, including journalists and filmmakers, secretly visited Israel, sparking controversy. The visit, facilitated by Israeli NGO Sharaka, aimed to promote cultural diplomacy. Read more on this developing story.

Amnesty International urges safe return of journalist Ahmad Noorani’s brothers

 March 20, 2025:  Amnesty International calls for an investigation into the enforced disappearance of journalist Ahmad Noorani’s brothers, condemning it as an attack on press freedom and human rights.