Gagging social media for Muharram not the answer: Dawn

 JournalismPakistan.com |  Published last year |  JP Staff Reporter

ISLAMABAD—Daily Dawn on Saturday opposed the Punjab government's request to the federal government to shut down social media platforms—Facebook, X, Instagram, WhatsApp, others—from Muharram 6 to 11.

"It is hoped that better sense prevails and the prime minister turns down the Punjab government's troubling suggestion calling for the gagging of social media apps during Muharram," the paper said in an editorial titled "Gagging Social Media."

The provincial administration had earlier written to the interior ministry, calling for a shutdown of various platforms— Facebook, WhatsApp, YouTube, X, etc.—between Muharram 6 and 11 "to control hate and avoid sectarian violence," citing the threat of "external forces" supposedly disseminating hate material.

There are 52.3 million WhatsApp and 47.5 million Facebook users in Pakistan.

"Security concerns are absolutely valid during Muharram, which begins either tomorrow or on Monday, but mass shutdowns of the internet and social media are not the most advisable method of ensuring peace," the paper stated.

The editorial argued that this policy focuses more on the symptoms—hate material and misuse of social media—rather than the actual disease—the presence of violent hate groups that have been fanning the flames of communalism in society for decades.

The newspaper feared that if allowed, it could set a precedent for some elements within the state to permanently throttle free expression and deny access to apps that have become integral to the lives of millions of Pakistanis.

"Shutting down apps can result in disrupting communication across the country, while businesses that depend on these platforms would face immense losses," the editorial concluded.

Read Next

PFUJ calls for end to Impunity for Crimes Against Journalists

 November 02, 2025: PFUJ urges Pakistan’s federal and provincial governments to end Impunity for Crimes Against Journalists and ensure their safety and press freedom.

Global impunity for journalist murders worsens as Pakistan sees 60 percent rise in attacks

 November 02, 2025: Impunity for crimes against journalists deepens worldwide as Pakistan reports a 60 percent surge in attacks and weak enforcement of safety laws.

Pakistan Press Foundation documents 137 attacks on journalists in 2025

 November 01, 2025: Pakistan Press Foundation reports 137 attacks on journalists in 2025, highlighting rising threats, legal harassment, and censorship on the International Day to End Impunity.

Anchor Talat Hussain laughs as Marwat makes vulgar comment on air

 November 01, 2025: A viral Samaa TV clip featuring MNA Sher Afzal Marwat’s crude remarks and Talat Hussain’s laughter raises questions about the declining ethics of Pakistani television.

Why was this DawnNews TV journalist targeted in a foiled murder plot?

 October 31, 2025: Police foiled a plot to kill DawnNewsTV journalist Tahir Naseer in Rawalpindi after arresting suspects hired for Rs200,000. Naseer says threats followed his reporting.

CPJ calls on Pakistan to prosecute killers of journalist Imtiaz Mir

 October 31, 2025: CPJ calls on Pakistan to bring Imtiaz Mir’s killers to justice after the journalist was allegedly murdered by a banned militant group in Karachi.

PFUJ urges quashing of fabricated case against journalist Matiullah Jan

 October 30, 2025: The PFUJ has condemned a fabricated drug case against journalist Matiullah Jan, calling it an attempt to silence him and urging authorities to quash the charges immediately.

NewsOne TV hit by layoffs and unpaid wages, channel remains on air

 October 30, 2025: NewsOne TV remains on air but faces mass layoffs and delayed salaries, exposing Pakistan’s worsening media crisis and financial instability.