Javed Chaudhry signs off from Express News after 18 years on ‘Kal Tak’ Why only Nukta, Mr. Minister? Media workers question government's selective support Information Minister Tarar announces jobs for all 37 laid off Nukta employees Faisal Chaudhry’s viral one-liner on G for Gharidah steals the show A digital dream falters: Nukta cuts 37 jobs in Pakistan after only one year Pulitzer Center offers global grants for in-depth journalism CPJ urges probe after journalist Rana Ayyub receives death threats in India Talat Hussain says offensive viral clip was edited out, not aired on Samaa TV Moldovan journalist Mariana Rață receives death threat after interview PFUJ recalls November 3, 2007 emergency as Pakistan’s darkest day
Journalism Pakistan
Journalism Pakistan

India's Supreme Court bans reporting judge's statements

 JournalismPakistan.com |  Published 8 years ago

Join our WhatsApp channel

India's Supreme Court bans reporting judge's statements

NEW DELHI - An Indian Supreme Court order banning news media from quoting a judge who accused other senior judges of corruption is a troubling blow to freedom of the press, the Committee to Protect Journalists said Wednesday.

A bench of the Supreme Court headed by Chief Justice Jagdish Singh Khehar sentenced CS Karnan, a judge at the Kolkata High Court, to six months in prison on charges of contempt of court and ruled that “no further statements made by him should be reported hereafter.”

The court in February 2016 stripped Karnan of his powers to pass judicial orders after Karnan accused senior judges of corruption, according to news reports.

The Supreme Court on May 1 ordered Karnan to undergo medical examination, according to media reports. The judge refused, and on May 8 ordered New Delhi police to imprison seven Supreme Court judges for five years and ordered them to pay fines on charges that they discriminated against him on the basis of his caste, according to media reports.

“The Indian Supreme Court’s blanket order barring any journalists from covering any statement from Justice CS Karnan amounts to prior censorship,” said Steven Butler, CPJ Asia program coordinator. “The court needlessly resorted to overly broad measures to silence allegations of significant public interest.”

The Indian Express daily newspaper defied the court’s order by reporting Karan’s statements in a news article today.

“Usually, it’s been the government trying to spin a narrative or hinder free and fair reporting and it’s been the Supreme Court which has stepped in to protect — and often expand — the contours of free speech," the newspaper said in an accompanying editorial. “But now, in an unusual departure, it’s the highest court which has banned the press from reporting on the orders of Justice C.S. Karnan.”

Alok Prasanna Kumar, a lawyer based in Bengaluru city, told CPJ it remained unclear whether The Indian Express would face legal consequences for publishing Karnan’s remarks.

“The court can issue a notice and haul them up for civil contempt,” Kumar said. “If that happens, they should say that the order is illegal. They were never named in it…and are justified in asking the court to recall the order.” – Committee to Protect Journalists

Explore Further

Newsroom
Iran tightens digital control with new wave of news site blockages

Iran tightens digital control with new wave of news site blockages

 November 07, 2025 Iran has intensified online censorship, blocking independent news sites and social channels, sparking protests from journalist groups over the growing suppression of press freedom.


Six journalists summoned in Turkey over coverage of detained opposition mayor

Six journalists summoned in Turkey over coverage of detained opposition mayor

 November 07, 2025 Six Turkish journalists have been summoned over coverage of opposition mayor Ekrem Imamoglu, raising fresh concerns about press freedom and political repression in Turkey.


Record journalist deaths in Gaza highlight deepening impunity crisis

Record journalist deaths in Gaza highlight deepening impunity crisis

 November 07, 2025 Over 285 journalists have been killed in Gaza since 2023, exposing a severe impunity crisis and raising calls for global action to protect press freedom.


Arab states tighten digital content laws, raising concerns over press freedom

Arab states tighten digital content laws, raising concerns over press freedom

 November 07, 2025 Arab states are tightening digital content laws, with new regulations in the UAE, Saudi Arabia, and Egypt raising fresh concerns about media freedom and online expression.


Pulitzer Center offers global grants for in-depth journalism

Pulitzer Center offers global grants for in-depth journalism

 November 05, 2025 The Pulitzer Center is offering global reporting grants for journalists worldwide, funding high-impact projects on underreported issues with rolling applications in 2025.